May 06, 2024Top roofers

If you live in Upper Arlington, you know our homes are distinct. From the historic slate and tile roofs “South of Lane” to the sprawling mid-century ranches in River Ridge, maintaining a home here requires more than just a hammer and nails.

Finding reliable roofers in Upper Arlington can be overwhelming, especially after the erratic weather we’ve seen in Central Ohio recently. But hiring the right contractor is critical—not just for the roof itself, but to navigate Upper Arlington’s strict zoning codes and permit requirements.

To help you make the right choice, we’ve curated a guide to the Top 10 Roofing Companies serving Upper Arlington. These experts were selected based on craftsmanship, local reputation, and customer service.

1. Exterior Alliance

Best For:Storm Restoration & Historic Home Compliance

As a locally owned company, Exterior Alliance understands the unique “micro-climate” of Upper Arlington. We know that the mature trees lining our streets often lead to moss growth and storm damage that other neighborhoods don’t face. We specialize in navigating the complex insurance claim process and handling the Certificate of Zoning Compliance required by the City of Upper Arlington, ensuring your new roof is 100% up to code.

The Exterior Alliance Difference: We don’t just replace roofs; we protect your home’s character. Whether you need to match a specific architectural shingle for an HOA requirement or need emergency tarping after a storm, our A+ rated team is your neighborly expert.

2. Erie Home

Best For:Metal Roofing Solutions

Erie Home is a national name with a strong local presence. They are particularly well-known for their metal roofing products that are stamped to mimic the look of traditional shingles or shake. This is a great option for Upper Arlington homeowners looking for longevity without sacrificing the traditional aesthetic.

  • Location: 1758 Dividend Dr, Columbus, OH 43228
  • Phone: (740) 293-4415
  • Website:eriehome.com
  • Services: Metal roofs, Asphalt roofs, Roof repair.

3. Bone Dry Roofing

Best For:Minor Repairs & Maintenance

One of the larger outfits in the Midwest, Bone Dry is a reliable option if you need general maintenance. Unlike some companies that only want full replacements, Bone Dry has a dedicated service department specifically for smaller repairs, which can be helpful for aging roofs in the area.

  • Location: 3500 Parkway Ln, Hilliard, OH 43026
  • Phone: (614) 602-5912
  • Website:bonedry.com
  • Services: Roof repair, Ventilation, Flat roofs, Asphalt roofs.

4. Muth & Company Roofing

Best For:Ventilation & Attic Insulation

Muth & Company has a long-standing reputation in Columbus. They place a heavy emphasis on proper attic ventilation, which is critical for the older housing stock in Upper Arlington to prevent ice dams during our freezing winters.

  • Location: 5951 Westerville Rd, Westerville, OH 43081
  • Phone: (614) 882-0900
  • Website:muthroofing.com
  • Services: Attic insulation, Ventilation, Skylights, Metal roofs.

5. Nitro Roofing and Construction

Best For:Specialty Slate & Wood Shake

If you own a historic home near the Scioto Country Club or Old Arlington, you may have slate or wood shake. Nitro Roofing is a strong contender for these heritage materials, offering specialized craftsmanship that standard shingle crews may lack.

  • Location: 4040 Fisher Rd, Columbus, OH 43228
  • Phone: (614) 601-1898
  • Website:nitroroofing.com
  • Services: Slate, Wood roofs, Copper/Metal, Asphalt.

6. Elements Roofing & Construction

Best For:Emergency Response

When a tree branch comes down in a storm, speed matters. Elements Roofing is known for their quick emergency tarping services to prevent water from damaging your interior while you wait for a full repair.

  • Location: 3192 Broadway, Grove City, OH 43123
  • Phone: (614) 557-8747
  • Website:columbusroofing.com
  • Services: Emergency tarp, Solar panel installation, Metal roofs.

7. The Metal Roof Company

Best For:Architectural Standing Seam

As the name implies, this is a niche company focused almost exclusively on metal roofing. If you are building a modern addition or want a “forever roof” with standing seam metal, they are a specific resource for that material.

  • Location: 2631 Morse Rd, Columbus, OH 43231
  • Phone: (614) 721-7663
  • Website:themetalroofcompany.com
  • Services: Metal roofs, Dormers, Skylights.

8. Kerrigan Roofing and Restoration

Best For:General Restoration

Kerrigan is a reliable general contractor for roofing and restoration. Located nearby in Dublin, they service the Upper Arlington area frequently and are well-versed in general exterior remodeling.

  • Location: 115 S High St Suite 200, Dublin, OH 43017
  • Phone: (614) 373-2519
  • Website:kerriganroofing.com
  • Services: Wood roofs, Ventilation, Roof repair.

9. Lifetime Quality Roofing

Best For:Solar Integration

Lifetime Quality has maintained a physical presence in Upper Arlington. They have recently focused heavily on the solar roofing market, making them a good option if you are looking to combine a roof replacement with energy efficiency upgrades.

  • Location: 5005 Horizons Dr STE 205, Upper Arlington, OH 43220
  • Phone: (614) 407-7663
  • Website:lifetimequalityroofing.com
  • Services: Solar panel installation, Metal roofs, Replacement.

10. AmeriPro Roofing

Best For:Standard Asphalt Replacements

AmeriPro is a large national company with a local branch. They are efficient at standard asphalt shingle replacements and are often seen working in neighborhoods after major hail events due to their large workforce capacity.

  • Location: 68 Dillmont Dr, Columbus, OH 43235
  • Phone: (614) 350-0102
  • Website:ameriproroofing.com
  • Services: Asphalt roofs, Roof repair, Quality inspection.

Upper Arlington Roofing FAQ

Do I need a permit to replace my roof in Upper Arlington?

Yes. The City of Upper Arlington is stricter than many surrounding suburbs. You typically need a building permit and, in some cases, a Certificate of Zoning Compliance. A reputable contractor (like Exterior Alliance) will handle this paperwork for you to ensure you avoid fines.

How do I handle ice dams on my UA home?

Upper Arlington has many older homes with insulation gaps that lead to ice dams. We recommend installing a high-grade “Ice & Water Shield” membrane on the eaves and ensuring your attic has proper intake (soffit) and exhaust (ridge) ventilation.

What should I do if a tree falls on my roof?

First, ensure your family’s safety. Then, call a roofer for an emergency tarping service immediately to stop water ingress. At Exterior Alliance, we can document the damage for your insurance claim to prove it was storm-related.

Ready for a Roof Inspection?

Don’t wait for a small leak to become a major renovation. Contact Exterior Alliance today for a free, no-obligation roof inspection. We are your neighbors, and we are here to help you protect your biggest investment.

Click Here to Schedule Your Free Estimate

Or call us at (614) 363-5012